Calvary Community Church

Sermon

Pilate and the Jews on Trial

Speaker
David Capoccia
Scripture
John 19:1-16

Reading Tools:

Aa

Auto Transcript

Note: This transcript and summary was autogenerated. It has not yet been proofread or edited by a human.

Summary

We are confronted with the profound ironies of Jesus’ Roman trial before Pontius Pilate, drawn from John 19:1-16. This passage teaches us that though Jesus stood before men as the accused, it was Pilate and the Jewish leaders who were truly on trial — and their rejection of the Son of God serves as a solemn warning to every hearer of the Word today.

Key Lessons:

  1. The mock coronation of Jesus — the crown of thorns, the purple robe, the soldiers’ homage — ironically affirms cosmic truth: Jesus really is the divine King, conquering sin and death through the very suffering inflicted upon him.
  2. Pilate’s repeated declarations of innocence expose where true guilt lies — not with Jesus, but with those who manipulate, coerce, and ultimately reject him despite the evidence of his righteousness.
  3. The chief priests’ declaration, “We have no king but Caesar,” is a bold blasphemy that reveals their rejection not only of Jesus, but of God’s kingship itself — a warning against religious profession without true submission to God.
  4. Every reader and hearer of this account faces their own “final jeopardy” — the question of how they regard Jesus determines their eternal destiny, with only two possible answers: rejection or saving faith.

Application: We are called to examine our own hearts honestly: do we treat Jesus as an inconvenience who threatens what we love, or do we behold his glory and surrender to him as Lord and Savior? We are urged to repent of whatever idols or sins hold us back and go “all in” on Jesus, trusting his guaranteed promise of eternal life.

Discussion Questions:

  1. In what ways might we, like Pilate, acknowledge Jesus’ innocence and even his authority while still failing to fully commit to him? What holds us back?
  2. The Jewish leaders said “We have no king but Caesar” — what modern equivalents of “Caesar” do people (or we ourselves) tend to serve instead of God?
  3. How does beholding Jesus’ silent, meek endurance of unjust suffering strengthen your own faith and trust in God during difficult circumstances?

Scripture Focus: John 19:1–16 forms the heart of this passage, showing the final ironies of Jesus’ Roman trial. Supporting passages include 2 Samuel 7:14 and Psalm 2:7 (the Davidic Messiah as Son of God), Leviticus 24:16 (the blasphemy charge), and John 3:12 (Jesus not casting pearls before those who refuse truth).

Outline

Introduction

Let’s give our attention to the word as we first beseech the Lord in prayer.

Heavenly Father, it’s been such a joy to praise Christ in song, but now God, show us Christ. Show us more of the glory of Christ from your perfect God-breathed word. Help me to be able to explain it.

And Holy Spirit, transform us by it. We beseech you, oh God. Amen.

One surprisingly advanced legal concept I learned as a young boy was the concept of double jeopardy.

In my early years, I didn’t have any special skill or interest in law, but I often watched a certain trivia game show called Jeopardy.

In this TV show, I’m sure most of you are familiar with it, contestants answered clues on various topics to win money.

Midway through each show, the contestants would enter a second round where the clues were worth double the money. This round was called double jeopardy.

As an elementary school student, the double concept was easy enough for me to understand. But what was jeopardy?

How did that differ from double jeopardy?

Thankfully, I had a walking encyclopedia in my house known as my mom.

One day I asked her about it and she explained that jeopardy is just another word for danger or risk.

Meanwhile, double jeopardy is a legal situation in which a person is tried and acquitted of a crime, but then put on trial again for the exact same crime. So, placing the person in the same legal danger again.

The US Constitution’s Fifth Amendment specifically forbids putting anyone into double jeopardy. This is a good thing. It prevents at least two kinds of injustice: one, trying a person again and again until you get the verdict you want, and two, bankrupting a person with endless legal fees.

Thank the Lord that we have this protection against double jeopardy in our country.

But the Lord Jesus, when he was on the earth, did not enjoy this kind of legal protection.

If we put together the four gospel records of Jesus’ Roman trial before his crucifixion, we see almost the exact situation that our law against double jeopardy was trying to prevent. At least four times we hear the presiding authority, Pontius Pilate, declare Jesus not guilty.

After preliminary investigation and interview, Pilate declares Jesus not guilty. After letting visiting King Herod also interview Jesus, Pilate declares Jesus not guilty. After failing to bargain for Jesus using Barabbas, Pilate declares Jesus not guilty.

And after humiliating Jesus before the Jerusalem crowd, Pilate again declares Jesus not guilty.

But the Jews were not willing to accept that verdict. They were going to keep pestering Pilate until he gave them the verdict that they desired.

Even when he eventually acquiesced, he did not say guilty. Rather, he pronounced, “I grant your request for his death.”

As readers and observers of this record of Jesus’ trial, what are we to think? What are we to think of Jesus’ trial before Pilate?

On the one hand, we see that Jesus is completely righteous and innocent. How many times does Pilate have to say it?

Even when he condemns Jesus, he can’t bring himself to say he’s actually guilty.

On the other hand, we see where real guilt lies. Not with Jesus, but with those who are responsible for his death.

Thus, in a trial full of ironies, one sobering irony stands out of Jesus’ Roman trial. Though Jesus technically was the one on trial before men, it was Pilate and the Jews on trial before God.

“Though Jesus technically was the one on trial before men, it was Pilate and the Jews on trial before God.”

How were they going to treat God’s son?

As we return to the Gospel of John today, we’ll finish looking at John’s account of Jesus’ Roman trial and we’ll consider how this passage is still relevant for another trial happening today.

Please take your Bibles and turn to John 19. We’ll be looking at John 19:1-16. And we will see Pilate and the Jews on trial.

If you’re using the Pew Bibles, you can find John 19:1-16 on page 183.

Context: Jesus’ Roman Trial

Before we look at our new passage, let’s reestablish the context. We’re in the Evangelistic Gospel of John, originally written so that Jews and other religious persons might truly believe in Jesus as the son of God and Messiah and gain eternal life.

By now, we’re in the second half of John’s gospel, and this half is all about showing Jesus’ glory and his special hour of suffering, his death, his burial, and his resurrection.

The cross isn’t simply Jesus’ means to glory. It is his glory, though in a highly unexpected way.

“The cross isn’t simply Jesus’ means to glory. It is his glory, though in a highly unexpected way.”

Recall that on Passover night, Jesus is betrayed, then arrested, and then condemned in a Jewish sham trial overseen by the high priests Annas and Caiaphas.

These then deliver Jesus to the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate, to carry out the execution. Much to the high priests’ annoyance, however, Pilate insists on conducting his own trial first.

What then plays out in John 18:28 to John 19:16 is a Roman trial of Jesus filled with profound ironies. An irony is an occurrence when someone says the opposite of what he means or when something happens that is the opposite of what one would normally expect.

Review: The First Three Ironies

Irony #1: The Prophecy-Confirming Arrangement

In his record, the Apostle John reports six ironic developments in Jesus’s Roman trial so that you will behold Jesus’s glory and believe. We saw the first three ironic developments last time we were looking at John. In John 18:28-32, we saw number one: the prophecy confirming arrangement.

To review. At dawn, the sinful Jewish leaders bring Jesus to Pilate at the Praetorium, the governor’s residence in Jerusalem. But they won’t go inside lest they contract ritual uncleanness from Gentiles.

The two sides, the Jews and Pilate, posture with one another, saying words that they don’t really mean to force the other side into a humiliated position. The Jewish leaders pretend that they don’t need to give a formal charge to the Roman governor to have Jesus executed. Just trust us.

Pilate then pretends that the Jewish leaders must not need Pilate’s help at all since the case cannot be important enough to involve the death penalty.

Ultimately, the Jewish leaders are forced to admit that they do need Pilate since only the Roman governor can oversee capital punishment, putting someone to death.

This means that Pilate can exercise his right to give Jesus a new trial, and he does.

Yet this arrangement between Pilate and the Jews, which will ultimately result in Jesus’s crucifixion—the most shameful and painful way that a person could die at that time—is not by chance. This was in fact prophesied by Jesus himself multiple times.

Jesus must literally and figuratively be lifted up on a Roman cross to save his people from their sins.

“Jesus must literally and figuratively be lifted up on a Roman cross to save his people from their sins.”

Irony #2: The Truth-Revealing Interrogation

In John 18:33-37, we saw another ironic development.

Number two, the truth revealing interrogation. The main charge the Jews bring against Jesus is that Jesus claims to be Christ, the King of the Jews. That means Jesus must be a treasonous and rebellious rival to Rome.

Pilate is determined to discover the truth of this claim. And Pilate does discover the truth. Yet the truth is way more profound than Pilate expects.

Jesus reveals to Pilate that Jesus is king, but of a heaven-sent kingdom. Jesus’s kingdom is not of this world. It is from heaven and it is unlike any other kingdom. His kingdom is not established by human power, and therefore he has no need of armed rebellions, which is why Jesus’s disciples are not fighting.

Furthermore, Jesus reveals that he is a king who came first to testify. Jesus indeed came into the world to be king but not to exercise literal dominion over land and people. Not yet.

Jesus came first to testify of the truth of God and of God’s salvation. A truth that is open to every person who is willing to hear, whether Jew or Gentile.

“Jesus came first to testify of the truth of God and of God’s salvation — open to every person willing to hear.”

Thus, Jesus told Pilate a truth way grander than whether Jesus was guilty of the Jews’s accusation.

But tragically, Pilate the investigator fails to recognize this truth. He recognizes that Jesus is not guilty of plotting against Rome. But Pilate fails to recognize that he is talking to the truth, the Son of God.

Irony #3: The Justice-Subverting Trade

Finally, in John 18:38-40, we saw a third ironic development.

Number three: the justice subverting trade.

As a result of his investigation, Pilate pronounces Jesus not guilty, which is a just finding.

Yet Pilate quickly discovers that the hostile Jewish leaders do not accept this verdict.

To win the gathering Jewish crowd and to allow the Jewish leaders to save face, Pilate proposes a trade. According to the Passover custom, he is to set free one currently held prisoner. Pilate offers on the one hand Jesus, whom he calls the king of the Jews, or Barabbas, a murderous bandit. Which would you like for me to free?

To Pilate’s shock, the Jews choose the actual rebel against Rome rather than their innocent Messiah.

They choose an evil son of the father—which is what Barabbas’s name actually means, son of the father—over the good son of the father, the righteous son of the father.

“They choose an evil son of the father over the good, righteous Son of the Father.”

Since Jesus was clearly innocent, to offer this deal was unjust.

Even more so, is it unjust to accept it?

Yet Pilate abides the people’s wishes and he releases Barabbas and leaves Jesus to face crucifixion.

But what happens next? Does Pilate give up on trying to release righteous Jesus?

Pilate does not. Which leads to three more ironies even more striking than the previous.

We’re going to now look at John 19:1-16 and the rest of the six ironic developments in Jesus’s Roman trial, given so that you will behold Jesus’s glory and believe.

Irony #4: The Mock-Worship Coronation

The fourth ironic development appears in John 19:1-7.

In John 19:1-7 we see the mock worshiping coronation.

As we go into our new section, let’s start by reading verses 1 to 3.

Pilate then took Jesus and scourged him.

And the soldiers twisted together a crown of thorns and put it on his head and put a purple robe on him. And they began to come up to him and say, “Hail, King of the Jews.” And to give him slaps in the face.

The Scourging and Royal Mockery

Notice from verse one that Pilate, right after failing to release Jesus with Barabbas, has Jesus scourged.

Reading that, we might think that Pilate is now preparing Jesus to be crucified. This is the way that Matthew and Mark describe events in their gospels. After Jesus is condemned, he’s scourged and then crucified.

Yet we should realize that those two writers, Matthew and Mark, compress the record of what happens to Jesus after Barabbas is chosen. Instead, Matthew and Mark omit what Luke describes as Pilate’s effort to release Jesus by punishing him first.

In other words, Jesus ends up being scourged twice before his crucifixion.

And John clarifies when and why Jesus is scourged the first time.

We have to ask, “What is scourging?” The Greek word translated scourged in our Bibles in verse one can also be translated whipped or flogged.

Indeed, the word could refer to one of three types of Roman corporal punishment, each with its own fancy Latin name. There was the fustigatio, a relatively light beating using fists or sticks. This would be punishment for minor offenses or just to give a person a warning.

There was the flagellatio, a more severe beating using whips. This would be punishment for more serious offenses.

And then there was the verberatio, a beating with a multi-thonged whip embedded with pieces of metal, bone, or glass on the ends to tear the victim’s flesh.

This last punishment was so brutal it could kill on its own and was not administered unless someone had already been sentenced to death.

The verberatio was mandatory before someone was crucified.

Now, as we read on here, you will discover that Pilate has not yet officially condemned Jesus.

So which type of Roman punishment should we understand by scourged in verse one? It must be the fustigatio, the relatively light beating.

Indeed, this fits with the description that we have in verses 1 to 3 as well as the descriptions that are given in Matthew and Mark when the soldiers mock Jesus, beat Jesus with their hands and strike him with a reed stick. That’s exactly what the fustigatio comprises.

Only after Jesus is officially condemned to the cross would he then receive the second scourging, the dreaded verberatio.

Notice though in verses 2 to 3 that the soldiers indeed are not simply beating Jesus but they are mocking him. They intend to humiliate him.

Hearing that he is being charged as king of the Jews, they first twist together a mock crown of thorns. The Greek word for thorns is pretty general, literally thorn plants, but it could refer to the 3 to 5 inch long and very sharp spines that grow on the date palm common to Israel.

Regardless, wherever these thorns came from, the soldiers carefully twist together the thorn plants into a kind of wreath crown for Jesus. And then they place it on his head.

The soldiers crown Jesus as king. Yet the crown is painful and no doubt causes him to bleed.

The soldiers then put a purple robe on Jesus, which is a little surprising because purple garments were exceedingly valuable. Where do the soldiers get this robe? And why would they waste it on some Jewish prisoner?

Perhaps this robe is the robe that King Herod sent Jesus back wearing to Pilate. Herod was rich enough that he could waste a purple cloak on Jesus for a good laugh.

Alternatively, perhaps this robe was actually an officer’s cloak and was more deep red than purple. The Tyrian purple, the purple that was from Tyre that was so much in fashion at that time, we probably wouldn’t say it was purple because it actually looked red.

One ancient writer described Tyrian purple as the color of dark coagulated blood. Such would fit with Matthew’s description of the soldiers putting a scarlet robe on Jesus.

It’s not that one writer got it wrong. It’s just that depending on your perspective, you could say, “Oh, that looks purple, Tyrian purple.” Or you could say, “Oh, that looks red.” It’s really the same color. So probably a soldier’s cloak.

Having crowned Jesus and having given him a royal robe, the soldiers then pretend to offer Jesus kingly homage. They take turns approaching him and giving him a royal acclamation.

Hail, King of the Jews.

But instead of taking hold of his feet or his hand to kiss, they raise their hands to slap his face.

The other gospels say the soldiers also bow before Jesus. They spit on him. They give him a reed scepter. And then they beat him repeatedly on the head with the reed, driving that thorny crown even deeper into his head.

Why are these Roman soldiers so hateful to Jesus? What did he do to them?

Well, unfortunately, because of the corruptness of the human heart, this behavior is typical of those with power over prisoners. Many times such will abuse and make sport of those who cannot fight back.

Furthermore, for these soldiers, Jesus represents the Jewish people. After all, this guy is Jewish and he’s even the king of the Jews. We can let loose how much we are annoyed and we hate those Jews.

Undoubtedly, Satan also is behind this, encouraging the efforts of these persons who are really his slaves to take out his own hatred on God’s son.

It’s a scene of heinous injustice, completely sacrilegious treatment. This is no mere man. This is God, God’s own precious son. And this is the way they will treat him.

How will Jesus respond? How does Jesus respond?

I mean, notice in the text, no response is mentioned. Jesus apparently just endures without a word and without retaliation.

Though he is God’s son, worthy of all right treatment and glory, he just entrusts himself to his father despite what he’s receiving.

And surely we see the profound irony of what plays out here because Jesus really is the king of the Jews. Though the soldiers mock, they really speak and act truer than they know.

As the king of the Jews, Jesus does deserve a royal robe, a royal scepter, even for Gentiles to bow down to him. Jesus even deserves a crown shaped as a victor’s wreath.

He is the king who through the very suffering that these men are administering is conquering. He is defeating sin, defeating death, and defeating Satan for his people.

“He is the king who through the very suffering these men are administering is conquering sin, death, and Satan.”

And the soldiers do not realize how appropriate this particular crown of thorns is. Because if this crown indeed has long thorns like those of the date palm, that means it looks like a radiant crown.

What’s a radiant crown? Well, it’s a crown with spines sticking out like rays of light. Think of the crown that’s on the Statue of Liberty. That’s a radiant crown.

In the ancient world, rulers sometimes wore or were depicted with radiant crowns to emphasize their divine status. Alexander the Great was sometimes depicted that way, as were Roman emperors.

So the soldiers think to mock Jesus with such a crown. Yet they have accidentally coronated Jesus as the divine king, which is who he really is.

So on the one hand, the irony of this scene strongly emphasizes the evil of these men and the righteousness of Jesus. What they ought to do to King Jesus, they only do with hateful contempt.

On the other hand, even these evildoers cannot help but affirm cosmic realities and highlight that Jesus is all that they mock because he obediently suffers through it all.

“Even these evildoers cannot help but affirm cosmic realities and highlight that Jesus is all that they mock.”

Behold the Man

Well, we see next how Pilate seeks to use all that takes place with Jesus as a tactic to release Jesus. Look now at verses four and five.

Pilate came out again and said to them, “Behold, I am bringing him out to you so that you may know that I find no guilt in him.” Jesus then came out wearing the crown of thorns and the purple robe.

Pilate said to them, “Behold the man.” Here we see Pilate’s injustice yet again. He not only has had an innocent man, the son of God himself, beaten and mocked, but Pilate then presents Jesus to the Jewish people in humiliation.

Behold the man, Pilate cries. Ecce homo is the famous Latin phrase.

Pilate thinks by presenting bruised, bleeding, thorn-crowned Jesus to the Jews this way, Pilate will prove that Jesus is no true threat to Caesar and thus is not guilty. It’s as if by presenting Jesus thus, Pilate were saying, just look at the guy. This pathetic one is the one you Jewish leaders are desperately determined to kill.

Where is his power? Where is his majesty? Where is his threat? Behold, he is just a man.

Here too, we as John’s readers should notice a great irony.

Pilate says, “Behold the man,” to draw attention to Jesus’ shame and weakness.

But those of the truth hear Pilate’s statement and behold Jesus’ glory.

Yes indeed, here is the man, our man, the God-man, the eternal word of God, incarnated and willing to be presented to his people in just this humiliation so that he could obey the Father and save his people’s souls.

“Those of the truth hear Pilate’s statement and behold Jesus’ glory — the God-man willing to suffer to save his people.”

But does this newest stratagem from Pilate work to release Jesus? Verse six.

So when the chief priests and officers saw him, they cried out, saying, “Crucify, crucify.” Pilate said to them, “Take him yourselves and crucify him, for I find no guilt in him.” If Pilate was hoping that roughing up Jesus and humiliating him would satisfy the blood lust of the Jewish leaders, he was quickly proved wrong. Actually, the sight of Jesus in this mock royal apparel just enrages them further.

Here indeed, they behold everything that they hate about Jesus.

He does seem to them to be a mere contemptible man with hubristic ambitions. He claims to be the Messiah, king, and even the son of God.

But look at him.

Where indeed is the majesty, the power, and the deliverance that would be fitting for God’s true Messiah?

Thus, the official religious leaders and their attendants immediately scream for Jesus’ death by crucifixion.

Pilate gives them a sarcastic and probably disgusted reply.

More literally, his words here are, “Take him yourselves and crucify, for I myself did not find cause for accusation in him.” So he contrasts himself versus them.

Now understand that this is not Pilate giving the Jews permission to kill Jesus. The sense is more like, “If you don’t like my verdict, crucify him yourself.” But that’s right. You can’t because I’m the governor.

At this point again, Pilate should, if he values justice, just release Jesus. He’s plainly innocent. Just release him.

But the Jewish leaders will not give up.

The Son of God Charge

Verse 7: “The Jews answered him, ‘We have a law, and by that law he ought to die because he made himself out to be the son of God.’”

Previously, the Jews via their leaders presented Jesus to Pilate merely as a political rebel. But now they bring up the real reason that they want Jesus dead. Jesus, they say, has broken the Old Testament law by claiming to be the son of God.

Now, did the law of the Jews, the Old Testament, indeed forbid anyone from claiming to be the son of God? Actually, no, not specifically.

Rather, in 2 Samuel 7:14, God himself promised to be the father to David’s seed, David’s descendant, whom he declares he would treat as a son.

And Psalm 2:7 records God saying to the Davidic human messiah, “You are my son. Today I have begotten you.”

So the Old Testament actually gives precedent for the Davidic Messiah to claim to be the son of God. Far from forbidden, it’s actually a precedent.

“The Old Testament actually gives precedent for the Davidic Messiah to claim to be the Son of God.”

The problem is, the Jews of Jesus’ day, especially the leaders, they just don’t believe this claim from Jesus.

They ignore Jesus’ divine miracles. They ignore Jesus’ divine teaching and instead take special issue with the intimate and equal relationship that Jesus claims to have with God the Father.

They assume against the evidence that Jesus could not be the son of God, even the one who is one with the Father, even the one who is before Abraham—”I am.”

And thus conclude that Jesus is blaspheming and should die according to what is prescribed in Leviticus 24:16. Leviticus 24:16 says in the first part, “Moreover, the one who blasphemes the name of the Lord, the name of Yahweh shall surely be put to death. All the congregation shall certainly stone him.” So that’s their rationale.

Yet why bring this issue up to Pilate? Pilate is a civil magistrate rather than a religious one. Why bring up this argument from their law?

Well, perhaps the Jews are simply requesting Pilate to help enforce their own rules. Hey, you’re the governor. Help us out here.

Or perhaps the Jews are merely explaining why they cannot accept Pilate’s verdict on Jesus.

Irony #5: The Authority-Citing Warning

Either way, this new information from the Jews gets Pilate’s attention and leads to another ironic development in verses 8 to 12. Number five, the authority citing warning.

We see an authority citing warning. Look at verse 8. Now, therefore, when Pilate heard this statement, he was even more afraid.

There’s something about what the Jews just said that scares Pilate. Our New American Standard 95 translation says he was even more afraid, suggesting that he was already frightened.

However, John has not mentioned any previous fear from Pilate.

So, how could he become more frightened?

Most likely, the phrase here is not necessarily saying that Pilate was scared before, just that he suddenly became greatly afraid.

But why should Pilate be so spooked? He’s the big bad governor after all.

Well, like most pagan Romans of his time, Pilate is probably very superstitious. The myths of his religion often depict the gods coming down in the form of men. And in those myths, those who mistreat these disguised gods often end up cursed or dead.

Add to this what Matthew records. Pilate’s wife has a scary dream about Jesus which she interprets as a sign that Pilate must not condemn that righteous man.

And then add what Jesus already told Pilate: “My kingdom is not of this world and for this cause I have come into the world to testify to the truth.”

Could Jesus indeed be divine?

What will happen to Pilate for mistreating a divine man?

Jesus Silences and Warns Pilate

Pilate wants to hold another private interview with Jesus, which we see play out in verses 9 to 11. We’ll read those together.

“And he entered into the praetorium again and said to Jesus, ‘Where are you from?’ But Jesus gave him no answer. So Pilate said to him, ‘You do not speak to me. Do you not know that I have authority to release you and I have authority to crucify you?

Jesus answered, ‘You would have no authority over me unless it had been given you from above. For this reason, he who delivered me to you has the greater sin.’”

Notice in verse 9 that Pilate starts picking up the conversation again where it last left off. More literally in the Greek, he asks, “From where are you yourself?” Jesus does not answer.

To which we might ask, why not? Ultimately, we don’t know. But the end of the previous conversation is suggestive.

Jesus presents himself to Pilate as the king of truth who came to testify to God’s truth. All who are of the truth, he says, will hear my voice. They do hear my voice.

But to that, Pilate made clear that he’s not interested. Not really interested in whatever truth Jesus has to share.

So now when Pilate starts asking questions again, Jesus in a fitting judgment does not present any more truth about himself to Pilate. It’s not as if Pilate would believe it.

I think of what Jesus told Nicodemus in John 3:12. “If I told you earthly things and you do not believe, how will you believe if I tell you heavenly things?”

Jesus chooses not to talk. But Jesus’s silence annoys Pilate. It strikes him as either stupid or arrogant. So he warns Jesus about the kind of authority that Pilate has over him. “I have authority to release you, and I have authority to crucify you. No, I’d start talking if I were you.”

Pilate is flexing his power as governor to intimidate Jesus. Yet this effort completely fails because Jesus knows and trusts the one who has the real power in this situation—his Father.

In fact, Jesus ends up turning the tables on Pilate and ironically gives Pilate an authority-citing warning.

“Jesus ends up turning the tables on Pilate and ironically gives Pilate an authority-citing warning.”

Now, something interesting happens here grammatically. This is going to get a little bit technical.

Notice the “it” of verse 11. Anytime we see a pronoun like “it” in a verse, it’s useful to make sure that we know what the “it” refers to. In grammatical terms, we’re looking for the antecedent to the pronoun. What word or what thing does the pronoun stand in for? Just looking at verse 11, the most obvious antecedent for the word “it” would be the word “authority”—if it were granted you from above. So this would mean that Jesus would be saying you would not have any authority over me unless God gave you that authority.

That makes a certain amount of intuitive sense, but it doesn’t fit well with the end of the verse because Jesus goes on to say, “For this reason, he who delivered me to you has the greater sin.” Wait a second. Because Pilate’s authority comes from God, Pilate is less accountable for his sin? Shouldn’t he be more accountable for abusing the derived authority?

Furthermore, the grammar of verse 11 does not support this interpretation because the pronoun and the noun do not match in gender. English doesn’t usually use grammatical gender, but a lot of other languages do, and Greek is one of them. The word “authority” is feminine and the “it” that we see in our passage is neuter. The grammar doesn’t fit with it being “authority.”

So then what does “it” refer to instead? What’s the antecedent for this pronoun? Most likely we as readers are supposed to infer an unstated noun.

Based on the context, the word is something like “situation.” Jesus is saying the “it” is this situation in which Jesus is innocent yet the Jews are demanding Jesus’s death from Pilate.

To elongate the thought a little bit for you: if this is correct, then Jesus would be saying to Pilate, “You would have no authority over me unless this difficult situation had been laid in your lap by God. You must now judge. Yet you yourself will be judged for your decision. And there’s no easy answer for you. You try to impress me with your power, but the fact is you are greatly constrained by circumstance.”

This sense fits with the end of verse 11. Pilate is not the initiator of Jesus’s unjust betrayal to death, but merely a circumstance-squeezed accomplice. Pilate will not bear the greater sin.

He who handed Jesus over to Pilate—and that’s singular, so we’re probably talking about a person, probably the Jewish high priest Caiaphas, who was overseeing this whole thing—he who handed Jesus over to Pilate has the greater sin.

Nevertheless, Jesus warns Pilate that he will still incur sin before a heavenly authority for betraying Jesus. “I know you’re constrained by circumstances. This was laid in your lap, but you’re still accountable. Heaven is the authority over you.”

“Jesus warns Pilate that he will still incur sin before a heavenly authority for betraying Jesus. Heaven is the authority over you.”

How does Pilate respond to this word? Beginning in verse 12, as a result of this, Pilate made efforts to release him. Pilate takes Jesus’s word to heart. He fears it. He keeps making efforts to release Jesus.

We’re not told exactly what these efforts are, but Pilate clearly does not want to put Jesus to death. He’s not a particularly just man. He’s not a righteous person, but he doesn’t want to execute Jesus.

The Jewish Blackmail

The Jews apparently catch wind of this, and they finally play their trump card against Pilate. Look at the rest of verse 12.

“But the Jews cried out, saying, ‘If you release this man, you are no friend of Caesar. Everyone who makes himself out to be a king opposes Caesar.’”

Why is this shouted word from the Jews the trump card? Because they are basically blackmailing Pilate.

You see, Pilate had not been a very good governor of Judea up to this point. A few times already, he had needlessly upset and brutalized the Jews to the point that they had complained to the Roman emperor about Pilate.

The emperor at this time was Tiberius Caesar, who was infamously paranoid and not above putting disloyal Roman officials to death. Pilate is already on thin ice with Tiberius.

If another Jewish complaint reaches Rome about Pilate, that will probably be the end of Pilate’s governorship and it could be the end of his life.

The Jews thus are making an implied threat to Pilate. If you release Jesus, who claims to be a king, then we will go and tell Caesar on you. We will tell him that you let a rebel against Rome get away even though we Jews were pressing you to do the right thing.

Pilate is indeed constrained by circumstances. He is hopelessly caught.

“If he releases Jesus, he faces the wrath of the Jews and Rome. If he condemns Jesus, he may face the wrath of God.”

If he releases Jesus, he will face the wrath of the Jews and he may face the wrath of Rome. But if he condemns Jesus, he may face the wrath of God.

What will Pilate choose?

Before we see Pilate’s answer, do you notice the great irony of this Jewish blackmail? By this implied threat, the Jews pretend to be loyal servants of Rome, even more loyal than the Roman governor.

The reality is that most of these Jews hate Rome. They hate its emperor and they desperately want to get rid of Rome’s control of Judea. Yet, because it is convenient for seeing Jesus crucified, the Jews will pretend for a moment to love Rome.

Irony #6: The Messiah-Rejecting Judgment

Well, how does Pilate respond? In verses 13 to 16, we come to the last ironic development in Jesus’s Roman trial. Again, written so that you will behold Jesus’s glory and believe. That’s number six.

The Messiah rejecting judgment. The Messiah rejecting judgment.

Look at verse 13 and the beginning of verse 14.

Therefore, when Pilate heard these words, he brought Jesus out and sat down on the judgment seat at a place called the pavement, but in Hebrew, Gabbatha.

Now, it was the day of preparation for the Passover. It was about the sixth hour. Stop there.

In these verses, John underscores the drama of what is about to happen. He pauses to identify especially the place, the day, the time that Pilate sits to pronounce judgment on Jesus.

What’s the place? It’s the stone pavement before the praetorium known to the Hebrews as Gabbatha. The day, it’s the day of preparation before the Sabbath, that is Friday during Passover.

The time, it’s the sixth hour, that is about six hours after sunrise or close to noon.

Remember Jesus’s Roman trial started at dawn or around 6:00 a.m. All the back and forth of Jesus’s Roman trial apparently has taken some hours.

By the way, Mark says that Jesus was crucified at the third hour, about 9:00 a.m.

So how does that fit with what’s reported here about Jesus about to be sentenced and then crucified at the sixth hour, 12:00 noon?

It’s a contradiction in the Bible.

Well, remember people didn’t have accurate and readily available timepieces back then, but instead used the position of the sun to estimate the time of day. When they did so, they estimated to the closest three-hour mark.

If the sun just rose, they’d say it’s 6 a.m. If the sun was about a quarter way through the sky, they’d say it’s about 9:00 a.m. If the sun was midway in the sky, they’d say it was about noon.

But what if the sun were in a position between a quarter and halfway through the sky? How would people describe it?

They would not say what we would say, something like, “Oh, it’s 10:30.” They certainly wouldn’t be that specific. They didn’t speak that way. They would either round up or round down to the nearest three-hour mark.

So one person might look at the sun between a quarter and halfway through the sky and say, “It’s 9:00 a.m.” While another might look at the same sun and say, “It’s 12:00 noon. It’s about noon.”

Just two different ways of looking at the same thing, but both accurate. That appears to account for the difference between Mark and John. Because Jesus was probably sentenced to crucifixion around 10:30 a.m. or so, John rounds up and his record says it’s about noon, while Mark rounds down and he says it’s about 9:00 a.m. Both of these are accurate.

Anyway, John gives us the drum roll and then he presents for us a final profound exchange, the rest of verses 14 and 16.

And he, Pilate said to the Jews, “Behold your king.” So they cried out, “Away with him! Away with him! Crucify him!” Pilate said to them, “Shall I crucify your king?” The chief priests answered, “We have no king but Caesar.” So he then handed him over to them to be crucified.

Pilate hates that the Jews have once again forced him to capitulate to their demands.

So he determines that if he must condemn innocent Jesus, he will at least try to humiliate the Jews in doing so.

Notice in verse 14 when Pilate brings out Jesus again, he doesn’t say, “Behold the man,” but behold your king.

Jesus doesn’t look any more honorable than before. So Pilate is essentially saying, “Here is your pathetic king, you pathetic people.” The Jews get what Pilate’s trying to do. Both the leaders and the people deny this humiliating association and instead insist on Jesus’s removal.

Away with him. Away with him, they say, which interestingly the Greek phrase translated that way is most literally lift up. Lift up in the sense of remove.

But that phrase for us readers should bring to mind the double meaning of lift up.

Lift up to die on a shameful cross, but lift up in glory for the universe.

Pilate doubles down in his attempt to humiliate the Jews. He asks again, “Shall I crucify your king?” He thus implies that the Jews are so contemptible that even their pathetic king deserves no other fate but the most shameful of deaths.

Pilate wants the Jews to shame themselves further by asking for it.

No, no, you can’t distance yourself from him. He’s your king. You really want me to crucify him?

We Have No King But Caesar

But the ring leaders of the Jewish plot, Annas, Caiaphas, and their other priestly associates, are one step ahead of Pilate. They answer with, “We have no king but Caesar.” In this statement, the priests deny Pilate the satisfaction of humiliating them and assert their complete loyalty to Rome.

It’s a savvy answer, but these top religious leaders, the shepherds of Israel, also speak bold blasphemy.

In saying “we have no king but Caesar,” they not only reject Jesus as Messiah, but they reject any Davidic Messiah, any king sent from God to shepherd his people.

More fundamentally, as the Old Testament declared that God was Israel’s king, these priests reveal their true colors and disavow even the kingship of God the Father.

“The priests reject any Davidic Messiah and disavow even the kingship of God the Father.”

They do speak true. We have no king but Caesar.

How terribly ironic that it is the chief priests who, instead of leading their people to God as is right, lead their people to reject both God and his Messiah to serve mere human rulers.

That is what’s ultimately going on here, isn’t it? Verses 14 to 16 are not just a conclusion of Jesus’s trial, but really the conclusion of the trial of Pilate and the Jews.

Think about what’s really being presented here. Both sides, Pilate and the Jews, have had the King of the Jews, the truth, Jesus the Christ, the Son of God, presented to them officially, even by coronation.

Both sides utterly reject him repeatedly, emphatically, clearly. No mistake. No “give us a redo.” They made it very clear: “I don’t want anything to do with this Jesus.”

Jesus proves inconvenient to them both.

He’s fundamentally inconvenient. He is a threat to earthly treasures and he’s a determined exposer of sin and idolatry, and that doesn’t make us feel good.

Ultimately, Jesus is not what these persons are looking for. Especially for the Jews, Jesus is not the kind of Messiah they’re looking for. They want someone who will affirm them in their own goodness and fulfill their earthly dreams. They’re not really interested in someone who’s going to show them God or call them to repentance.

Thus, while Jesus in holy meekness—but not weakness—endures this final heinous rejection by his own people and submits to an unjust death by crucifixion.

“Jesus in holy meekness — but not weakness — endures this final heinous rejection and submits to an unjust death.”

Pilate and the Jews find themselves rejected by the King of Life and thus condemned forever.

But what about you?

The Trial That Is Still Happening

I told you that this trial of Pilate and the Jews is relevant today because it’s still going on. It is still going on, but just for new defendants.

You see, when you read or hear these words, the words of Jesus, Jesus is no longer the one on trial.

You are.

If I may come back to my introduction, every episode of Jeopardy features a final Jeopardy question in which the contestants must wager some or all the money they earned in the show and answer a final, usually game-winning question.

Well, you too as listeners to God’s word also face a final jeopardy in the truest sense of final and jeopardy.

The wager has been set for you. It is your eternal soul.

“You too face a final jeopardy in the truest sense. The wager has been set for you — it is your eternal soul.”

The question is also set for you. It’s very simple, but it must be answered truthfully.

Final Jeopardy: How Do You Regard Jesus?

How do you regard Jesus?

Do you regard Jesus as Pilate and the Jews did, as a threat and an inconvenience?

You have various goals for your life. You have various things that you enjoy, sins even that you indulge, sin habits that you do not put off. Jesus is inconvenient.

Jesus gets in the way of what you really want, what you think will be fulfilling. It’s not necessarily that you hate Jesus. It’s just that you love other things and you love other people more.

If that is the case for you, if that is what your heart answers to this final Jeopardy question, then you must share the same fate as Pilate, Annas, Caiaphas, and all the unbelieving Jews of Jesus’s day. What is that fate?

Eternal hell.

There is only one savior, the beloved son of God. If you will not come to him, if you will not regard him as he deserves, then there is no other hope. God must judge you for rejecting his son.

But if your heart answers differently, if you regard Jesus differently, even in this account as you read through it or hear it read, you don’t see a mere moral teacher. You don’t see a tragic victim. You don’t see a good example. You see more than that.

You see what John is trying to get you to see. What the Holy Spirit wants you to see. The glorious son of God who yes will endure this incredibly humiliating and painful and ironic degradation for you, an undeserving sinner, and for his father whom he loves infinitely.

If you see his courage, if you see his righteousness, if you see his excellence in every way and you are drawn to him. You believe his word. You believe his promises. Even the promise that the kingdom of God is at hand.

Therefore, repent and believe and you will enter into that kingdom. If that’s what you see and that’s how your heart answers this final Jeopardy question, then what will the result be?

You gain the son of God and you gain eternal life.

“If that is how your heart answers this final Jeopardy question, you gain the Son of God and you gain eternal life.”

It’s not even a maybe or probably. It’s guaranteed.

Multiple times in the scriptures, but even explicitly in the New Testament, Jesus says, “Come to me all you who are weary and heavy laden, and I will give you rest.” You recognize your sinfulness. If you will give up your sins, the things that you did love more than Jesus, the ways you thought and the behaviors you practiced that are contrary to God’s will.

If you’ll give those up and say, “Jesus, I want you. I want life in your kingdom. I want to know you and I want to follow you,” Jesus guarantees you can have me. I am so glad to give myself to you. You not only will have eternal life, you have it immediately. My own life in you. You now know the father through me, which is the essence of eternal life.

Matthew 11:28: “Come to me all you who are weary and heavy laden, and I will give you rest.”

It’s really only two ways to answer that final Jeopardy question. Either you hate Jesus because he’s inconvenient, or you love Jesus and you’ll be with Jesus forever.

What does your heart answer?

John writes these things to us. He writes this whole book so that we will not be like the Jews who are led astray by their wicked leaders. Though very religious, they thought they knew God and loved God, but they didn’t actually know God because they rejected his son. John wants different for us.

He writes so that we may believe in Jesus as Lord and Savior and join a new people, the people of God. It is the experience of many of you. You’ve come from a religious family but not truly believing. What happened after you believed? Those religious persons in your family many times they don’t want anything more to do with you. They cut you off or they persecute you. That does happen for followers of Christ. It happened for John’s original listeners.

But he encourages them and he encourages us. Don’t fear that because you gain a new people and you gain God. Will you stand with God and his persecuted people, or because that’s too inconvenient, will you stand with religious unbelievers and perish? John says stand with Jesus and follow after him.

Those of us who believe are going to affirm that in just a moment at the Lord’s table. But before we do that, let’s pray to God.

Lord Jesus, we see so many wonders in this account. Layers of profundity.

On the one hand, you were not at all treated the way you ought to be treated. It was the exact opposite. What terrible injustice, what blasphemy, what sinfulness. I feel like we can’t even think of a strong enough word to describe it.

Yet at the same time, ironically, you were being affirmed in all the things that you are. And you were demonstrating your perfect righteousness, your obedience to the father, and you’re conquering and procuring salvation for your people. Jesus, we do behold your glory.

Oh God, take our eyes away from the false glory of the things of the world, the things that we so often value and then lead us to complain or get into conflict. Lord, let them be put on you again, our eyes beholding you and so satisfied in you.

Oh Jesus, please break us from the idols and the sins of the world which so often entice us and then leave us wrecked. Instead, God, let us enjoy you and your way. You are, even as you’ve said so many times in this gospel, determined that your joy and your peace will be in your people.

Let that be our experience here at Calvary continually more and more. And for those, God, who have not yet crossed over from mere religiousness to the kingdom of God, I pray that they would cross over today. That they would let go of whatever hold is holding them back from going all in on Jesus and they would be saved.

Lord, we look forward to worshiping you now and remembering the Lord’s table. Help us to do that in Jesus’s name. Amen.

Share this sermon: