Auto Transcript
Note: This transcript and summary was autogenerated. It has not yet been proofread or edited by a human.
Summary
We are reminded that God’s gracious provision in the wilderness tests Israel’s faith—and ours. Across three wilderness trials (Marah, the wilderness of Sin, and Rephidim), Israel repeatedly fails by grumbling and disobeying, yet God patiently provides water, manna, and quail without immediate punishment. These experiences, written for our instruction, expose the deep idolatry of the heart that drives sinful complaining and call us to trust God’s perfect provision.
Key Lessons:
- Sinful complaining is not merely about circumstances—it is ultimately directed against God, who sovereignly ordains all things, including difficult leaders and situations.
- There is a vital difference between righteous and unrighteous complaining: righteous complaint goes to God in faith, trusting He will make things right; unrighteous complaint springs from unbelief, self-centeredness, and heart idolatry.
- God is ‘long of nose’—slow to anger and rich in mercy—yet His patience must never become an excuse for sin, as complaining is listed alongside idolatry as that which disqualifies people from entering God’s promised rest (1 Corinthians 10:10).
- God provides through means and miracles alike, calling us to faithful obedience and wise stewardship while trusting that all true provision flows from Him alone.
Application: We are called to identify the heart idols that fuel our complaining, repent of them, and replace grumbling with contentment and thankfulness in Christ. By not complaining, we shine as bright stars in a dark world and worship God as He deserves.
Discussion Questions:
- When you complain about a person, a circumstance, or an object, how does reframing it as a complaint against God’s sovereign ordering of your life change how you feel about it?
- What specific idol or unmet desire tends to drive your most frequent complaints, and what would it look like to bring that to God in righteous, faith-filled prayer instead?
- How does God’s patient, repeated provision for faithless Israel encourage you when you feel that your own track record of unbelief disqualifies you from His care?
Scripture Focus: Exodus 15:22–27 (Marah: bitter water made sweet, God as healer); Exodus 16:1–36 (manna and quail: daily provision testing daily faith); Exodus 17:1–7 (water from the rock at Rephidim); Philippians 2:14 (do all things without grumbling); 1 Corinthians 10:10 (grumblers destroyed by the destroyer).
Outline
- Introduction
- Setting the Stage: Israel’s Wilderness Journey
- The First Test: Bitter Water at Marah (Exodus 15:22–27)
- What Is Complaining? Righteous vs. Unrighteous
- God’s Provision and Grace at Marah
- The Second Test: Hunger in the Wilderness of Sin (Exodus 16:1–36)
- Manna from Heaven: What Is It?
- Israel’s Disobedience and God’s Continued Mercy
- Why God Provides Through Means
- The Third Test: No Water at Rephidim (Exodus 17:1–7)
- Application: The Sin of Complaining
Introduction
Well, good morning everyone. Welcome to Sunday school. Please find your seats.
We’re moving along in our study of the life and ministry of Moses.
Last week, we saw God’s climactic deliverance of Israel at the Red Sea, or better the Reed Sea. That’s more literal to the Hebrew.
You would think that such a great deliverance standing like a capstone on a whole series of mighty plague judgments would have made a lasting impression on the people of Israel leading to ongoing holiness.
But as we alluded to at the end of the last lesson, this is not what happens.
Setting the Stage: Israel’s Wilderness Journey
To get to their promised land, Israel must cross a vast and life-threatening desert and stop at a certain mountain along the way. Meanwhile, God will test Israel by specifically bringing them to various desperate and uncomfortable situations.
God will ultimately provide for his people in these situations. He will provide wonderfully.
But how will Israel fare in the tests?
Spoiler alert: Israel will not do well. Instead, they will turn to constant complaining.
So then how will God respond to his people in their faithlessness?
And then what about us? How do we respond when we are brought into difficult circumstances?
Do we remember our mighty delivering God and continue to trust in him? Or do we despair, complain, and sin?
“Do we remember our mighty delivering God and continue to trust in him? Or do we despair, complain, and sin?”
These experiences of Israel in the wilderness, the New Testament tells us, were written for our instruction. So let’s pay close attention this morning as we see how God provides in the wilderness. Now, allow me to pray and then we’ll get into it.
God, we are in need of this instruction. We are not sanctified the way that we need to be. And perhaps, God, there are some here who are not even saved, who have not yet come to that faith-filled dependence that is salvation.
God, I pray that you would do a mighty work even through this Sunday school lesson this morning. Help me to be able to explain what your precious word says.
Please change us, God. Please change us. Help us to put aside complaining and put on thankfulness and trust. Amen.
Okay, please take your Bibles and open to Exodus 15, the second book of the Bible.
Last time we were in Exodus 14 with the Red Sea deliverance.
Exodus 15 begins with singing and dancing as the people memorialize what God just accomplished on behalf of Israel.
The First Test: Bitter Water at Marah (Exodus 15:22–27)
But the journey resumes in Exodus 15:22-27, which is where we see the first wilderness test of Israel. Let’s read that section. Exodus 15:22-27.
Then Moses led Israel from the Red Sea, and they went out into the wilderness of Shur, and they went three days in the wilderness, and found no water.
When they came to Mara, they could not drink the waters of Mara, for they were bitter. Therefore, it was named Mara. So the people grumbled at Moses, saying, “What shall we drink?” Then he cried out to the Lord, that is Yahweh. And Yahweh showed him a tree, and he threw it into the waters, and the waters became sweet.
There he made for them a statute and regulation, and there he tested them.
And he said, “If you will give earnest heed to the voice of Yahweh your God, and do what is right in his sight, and give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases on you which I have put on the Egyptians. For I, Yahweh, am your healer.” Then they came to Elim, where there were 12 springs of water and 70 palms, and they camped there beside the waters.
Right, we’ve read the passage. Let’s now make basic observations.
Notice in verse 22 where Moses leads the people, the wilderness of Shur. Where’s that?
Well, people put the wilderness of Shur in different places depending on their idea of where the Red Sea or Reed Sea crossing took place and where they think Mount Sinai is. However, verses like Genesis 16:7 and 1 Samuel 15:7 indicate that Shur is directly east of ancient Egypt. So the Reed Sea was very likely not the Red Sea. We talked about that last time.
Anyway, we’re directly east from Egypt in the wilderness for sure. Now notice also in verse 22 that Israel travels three days into this wilderness.
And remember what we’re talking about when we use the term wilderness, or rather when the Bible does. We’re not talking about the green beauty of Yosemite National Park or the forests of New Jersey. We’re talking about desert and arid brushland more typical of Southern California.
And as this travel is taking place around March or April because of its Passover connection, we’re probably looking at hot days under an unceasing sun in this desert and brushland. Thus, man and beasts get extra thirsty and they are quite uncomfortable as they work, eat, and walk in the heat.
On top of this, note the last detail of verse 22: they found no water.
Now, surely Israel has brought some water as they go into the desert, but water supplies are getting low. Humans can only go three or four days without drinking water before they die. But they have animals to care for too.
So surely the Israelites at this point are rationing the water they have. And they know that if they don’t find more water soon, both people and animals are going to start getting sick and they’re going to start dying.
“If they don’t find more water soon, both people and animals are going to start getting sick and dying.”
You can imagine the temptation to anxiety that this would cause the people.
But wait, verse 23—they found water. Yay. But what’s the problem? It’s bitter. It’s too bitter to drink.
Now, bitter could refer to the water’s extremely nasty taste. I imagine slimy, sulfur-filled water or water that’s very salty or mineral-laden. I don’t know if you’ve ever had to drink water like that before, but would you want to? Probably not. But bitter could also refer to something that’s actually poisonous. Revelation 8:11 describes a future time of judgment when many people will actually die from drinking bitter water—bitter water that was formerly fresh.
So it could be poisonous, it could be bad tasting, it could be both.
Notice in verse 23 that the people named the place Mara. And you might have a note in your Bible that says what Mara means. What does Mara mean? Bitter or bitterness. And by the way, this isn’t the only place that name appears in the Bible. Where else does it appear? The book of Ruth. You remember Naomi? She says, “Don’t call me Naomi anymore. Call me Mara because the Lord has dealt bitterly with me.” Mara turns out to be a very appropriate name for this place because it’s not just the waters that are bitter.
“It’s not just the waters that are bitter at Mara—the people’s hearts are bitter too.”
Notice how the people react to their disappointment in verse 24. They grumble. They complain.
What Is Complaining? Righteous vs. Unrighteous
Now, it’s worth taking time to clarify what grumbling and complaining actually are. Grumble and complain are largely synonyms.
Grumbling, we assume, is usually done a little more quietly.
But what does it mean to complain?
Complaining is not simply expressing pain or displeasure. If you, for example, say “I’m hungry” or “our politicians are so corrupt,” you are not necessarily complaining.
Biblically, to complain is to express that something is out of order and needs to be fixed. Thus, the statement “I’m hungry” becomes a complaint when it is said in such a way to mean not only am I hungry, but someone needs to do something about it right now. Often this kind of complaint is expressed in the form of a whine, as parents know.
Likewise, the statement “Our politicians are so corrupt” might be understood as a complaint depending on the statement’s context. Consider the difference between “Wow, our politicians are so corrupt”—that’s just an observation—versus “Ugh, our politicians are so corrupt”—that’s a complaint.
Now, here’s the important question: Is complaining a sin?
I’m hearing a few answers here. Very astute answers. It actually depends.
Complaining is a lot like anger. When we think about human anger, almost always it’s sinful. When we think about human complaining, almost always it’s sinful, but not necessarily.
Because it is characteristically sinful, human complaining is characteristically sinful in man. We have prohibitions in the Bible like Philippians 2:14. This may be a verse well known to parents.
Philippians 2:14: “Do all things without grumbling or disputing.”
Righteous Complaining: Faith in Disorder
Don’t do that. Grumbling is sinful. Do all things without it. But there is such a thing as righteous complaining.
Many psalms perfectly penned by the spirit of God were given as models and examples for God’s people. They express complaints to God. Psalm 43:2: “For you are the God of my strength. Why have you rejected me? Why do I go mourning because of the oppression of the enemy?”
These are not the statements of a dispassionate inquirer saying, “Hey, I’m just wondering about this, God.” No, this is a righteous man saying, “God, this situation is out of order. It makes no sense. Why have you brought these things to pass? Surely you will fix this.”
Consider the souls of martyrs as another example. They will complain to God in the last days about the lack of justice for their deaths. Revelation 6:10: “And they cried out with a loud voice, saying, ‘How long, oh Lord, holy and true, will you refrain from judging and avenging our blood on those who dwell on the earth?’”
Again, we cannot say that this is mere information seeking in the form of a question. Rather, these dead saints are crying out to God in a loud voice, noting that there is a terrible situation that continues to remain out of order in the world.
Even Jesus at times complains during his earthly ministry, like when he told his disciples after they failed to cast out a demon from a boy. Luke 9:41: “And Jesus answered and said, ‘You unbelieving and perverted generation, how long shall I be with you and put up with you?’ Jesus complains, too.
We’ll see later in our passage, even here in Exodus, that Yahweh frequently complains against his disobedient people.
So complaining is not always sinful, but it characteristically is. What is the difference between righteous and unrighteous complaining?
What would you say, Mark?
Okay. So two things I want to highlight from what Pastor Mark just said. He had the idea that it’s an accusation against God, and even if it’s said towards another person, it’s actually directed towards God. We’re going to come back to both of those ideas in just a second, but yeah, I think that’s part of what I think is the fundamental answer.
Anna, yeah, Anna, I think hits on something else that’s valuable to note. Sinful complaining comes from a heart that’s not content, not grateful. I think we can actually collect both of those answers into a more fundamental answer. The difference between unrighteous and righteous complaining is faith. Faith in God.
Righteous complaining, while acknowledging apparent disorder in the world, even an apparent failure from God to keep his promises, nevertheless stands in faith. Righteous complaining says, “God, this does not seem right according to who you are and what you’ve promised. So I’m expressing it to you to make it right.
“Righteous complaining says, ‘I know you will make it right because you are good and always keep your promises.’”
I know you will make it right or you will show me how it’s already right because you are good and always keep your promises.” And so until you show me vindication, I will be satisfied and continue to worship you and obey.
So coming back to Pastor Mark’s idea, this kind of complaining does not truly find fault with God even though it boldly approaches God. Listen to some of the things that you see in the Psalms or in the book of Job. At the same time, there is that trust, and there is, going back to Anna’s idea, there is that satisfaction.
God, I report this to you so that you’ll do something about it. It’s not right, but I am content until you make it right.
Unrighteous Complaining: Unbelief Against God
But what does unrighteous complaining essentially say?
Usually unrighteous complaining is not specifically directed towards God. It’s often directed towards a person or it’s spoken about a person. Unrighteous complaining says, “This situation is not right and it’s all so-and-so’s fault. He failed to do what he was supposed to do and he deprived me of something I need right this moment to be content, to be happy.”
I don’t have any faith that anyone will necessarily set things right in the future. And so until my circumstances radically change, I am justified in being angry, bitter, anxious or depressed.
I am further justified in hurting, bad mouthing and disobeying anyone who did this hurt to me.
Do you see the difference?
Righteous complaint is given in faith while unrighteous complaint is given in unbelief.
“Righteous complaint is given in faith while unrighteous complaint is given in unbelief.”
Righteous complaint really is an expression of worship to God. God, this is not right. I know your heart says the same thing. I agree with you, but I trust you. Whereas unrighteous complaint is an expression of worship too, but not of God, of self, or of some other earthly treasure.
As I said, though unrighteous complaint is usually directed at or spoken about a person on the earth, we’ll see later on that such complaining really is spoken against God.
Even if you’re complaining about a person sinfully, you’re really complaining against God.
“Even if you’re complaining about a person sinfully, you’re really complaining against God.”
Now, back to Exodus 15:24, we observe the people complain. And notice against whom they complain? Moses. And this is typical of people, isn’t it?
Something goes wrong. Whom do you blame? The leader.
Moses has been leading us and look what he’s given us. Nothing but bitter water. Some leader he is.
Side note, how would Moses know where to go in the wilderness? Yeah, they’re being led by God himself. It’s not like Moses said, “Let me calculate this. Okay, we’re going to do…” He’s following God’s direction. So whose leadership and direction is really being questioned here? It’s God’s. It’s Yahweh God.
God’s Provision and Grace at Marah
But now notice verse 25. How quickly everything changes.
Moses cries out to Yahweh. Yahweh shows Moses a tree. Moses throws the tree into the waters, some kind of spring creek or lake. And what happens? The bitter waters become sweet.
Wow. That was easy. All this anxiety and bitterness and complaint for nothing.
Because look at what Yahweh through Moses is able to do. Now you’ve got drinkable water, good water, sweet water.
Why were you so worried? Oh, ye of little faith.
Notice the rest of verse 25 where it tells us that God tested the people.
Now this test cannot refer to verses 26-27 because there’s no test mentioned there. So the test must refer to what just came before: the lack of water and then the bitter water at Mara. This experience, this site, it was testing.
God brought the people to a place of testing. He put them through a difficult circumstance to reveal what was in their heart. Now is that because God didn’t know?
God always knows, but he wants to make it known to them and to really the universe, even to us who read about it. Now verses 25 and 26 also give a statute and regulation, a rule, and we may paraphrase the rule this way: If you listen to God, believe and obey, God will protect you from suffering any of the plagues of Egypt. That’s the rule.
Now notice the reason God gives for this rule at the end of verse 26. He says, “For I, Yahweh, am your healer.” That’s kind of beautiful. Notice how personal that statement is. God uses his special covenant name with them.
Yahweh sounds like the Hebrew for “he is.”
And God says, “Your healer.” He’s not the healer of Egypt or of others who do not know him. Here he says, “I am your healer.” What a grace. What a privilege the people of Israel have: God himself, Yahweh God, as their healer.
The word healer can also be translated physician.
Either way, the idea is that God is the one who will delight personally to see to it that his people are well cared for and provided for.
“God is the one who will delight personally to see to it that his people are well cared for and provided for.”
Then notice verse 27. They arrive at this place called Elim.
Anything strike you about this new location compared to their previous experience in the wilderness of Shur and Mara?
There’s tons of water. It says there are seven springs of water and a whole bunch of date palms.
Wow. I think that’s significant. With these observations, let’s consider a few questions of interpretation.
How did the tree make the bitter water sweet?
It’s a miracle. No, no, no. Let’s not go into the “Oh, but maybe there’s something in the tree and it interacted.” No, there’s no known natural way for this to happen. It was just God miraculously providing for his people. He wanted to show them his power and his kindness.
What is the significance of God leading the people to Elim after Mara, a place of abundant water, when they were just in a place with no water?
Why?
Okay, so this is God showing his ability to provide. I think we can go even further than that. God is showing he knows what he’s doing.
It’s not like, “Oh, I really messed up before and I can’t find you guys water.” He’s like, “If I want to get you to a place of abundant water, I can. Look, 70 date palms, all these springs.
I can do it. Trust me. One way or another, I’m going to get you exactly what you need.” As Eric was saying, God is showing his faithfulness. He is able to provide generously.
Now the statute of verse 26 begins with an if statement.
Though the statement is given positively, we can understand what’s implied negatively. What will be the outcome if Israel does not listen, trust and obey God?
Exactly. Even what kind of judgments?
Exactly. The plagues of Egypt. The plagues of Egypt will come upon them if they do not listen because they will deserve it.
Now, the people here manifest a lack of trust in God and a failure to reverence God’s chosen leader for them, Moses. But notice, there is no punishment. There is no discipline mentioned in this passage.
So, what does this passage show us about God?
Yeah, he’s a merciful God. He’s slow to anger. That’s one of the things that the Old Testament, even in the Torah, is going to say again and again about God. He is slow to anger. I was explaining this to somebody the other day. The idiom in Hebrew is literally “long of nose.” Because the Hebrews, when they thought of anger, they thought of air rushing out of your nose. So if somebody was long of nose, that meant that it took them a long time before the air came out of their noses when they were angry. And they said, “That’s the way God is.
God is gracious. God is patient. God is generous even to those who don’t deserve it.
“God is gracious. God is patient. God is generous even to those who don’t deserve it.”
So Israel learned an important lesson at Mara about trusting God.
The Second Test: Hunger in the Wilderness of Sin (Exodus 16:1–36)
Or did they? God is going to test the people again with slightly different circumstances. And let’s see how the people react this time. Let’s go to the next chapter. Exodus 16:1-36 and we’ll read the whole thing. This is a longer section, so follow along with me.
Exodus 16: Then they set out from Elim and all the congregation of the sons of Israel came to the wilderness of Sin, which is between Elim and Sinai, on the 15th day of the second month after their departure from the land of Egypt. The whole congregation of the sons of Israel grumbled against Moses and Aaron in the wilderness. The sons of Israel said to them, “Would that we had died by Yahweh’s hand in the land of Egypt when we sat by the pots of meat when we ate bread to the full, for you have brought us out into this wilderness to kill this whole assembly with hunger.”
Then Yahweh said to Moses, “Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you, and the people shall go out and gather a day’s portion every day, that I may test them, whether or not they will walk in my instruction.” On the sixth day, when they prepare what they bring in, it will be twice as much as they gather daily. So Moses and Aaron said to all the sons of Israel, “At evening you will know that Yahweh has brought you out of the land of Egypt, and in the morning you will see the glory of Yahweh, for he hears your grumblings against Yahweh.
And what are we that you grumble against us?” Moses said, “This will happen when Yahweh gives you meat to eat in the evening and bread to fill in the morning. For Yahweh hears your grumblings, which you grumble against him. And what are we? Your grumblings are not against us, but against Yahweh.
Then Moses said to Aaron, “Say to all the congregation of the sons of Israel, come near before Yahweh, for he has heard your grumblings.” It came about as Aaron spoke to the whole congregation of the sons of Israel, that they looked toward the wilderness, and behold, the glory of Yahweh appeared in the cloud. And Yahweh spoke to Moses, saying, “I have heard the grumblings of the sons of Israel.
Speak to them, saying, ‘At twilight you shall eat meat, and in the morning you shall be filled with bread, and you shall know that I am Yahweh your God.’” So it came about at evening that the quails came up and covered the camp.
And in the morning, there was a layer of dew around the camp. When the layer of dew evaporated, behold, on the surface of the wilderness, there was a fine flake-like thing, fine as the frost on the ground. When the sons of Israel saw it, they said to one another, “What is it?” For they did not know what it was.
And Moses said to them, “It is the bread which Yahweh has given you to eat.” This is what Yahweh has commanded: “Gather of it every man as much as he should eat. You shall take an omer a piece according to the number of persons each of you has in his tent.”
And the sons of Israel did so. And some gathered much and some little. When they measured it with an omer, he who had gathered much had no excess, and he who had gathered little had no lack. Every man gathered as much as he should eat.
Moses said to them, “Let no man leave any of it until morning.” But they did not listen to Moses, and some left part of it until morning, and it bred worms and became foul. And Moses was angry with them.
They gathered it morning by morning, every man as much as he should eat. When the sun grew hot, it would melt.
And on the sixth day, they gathered twice as much bread, two for each one. When all the leaders of the congregation came and told Moses, then he said to them, “This is what Yahweh meant. Tomorrow is a Sabbath observance, a holy Sabbath to Yahweh. Bake what you will bake, and boil what you will boil, and all that is left over, put aside to be kept until morning.” So they put it aside until morning, as Moses had ordered. And it did not become foul, nor was there any worm in it.
Moses said, “Eat it today, for today is a Sabbath to Yahweh. Today you will not find it in the field. Six days you shall gather it, but on the seventh day, the Sabbath, there will be none.
It came about on the seventh day, that some of the people went out to gather, but they found none. Then Yahweh said to Moses, “How long do you refuse to keep my commandments and my instructions? See, Yahweh has given you the Sabbath.
Therefore, he gives you bread for two days on the sixth day. Remain every man in his place. Let no man go out of his place on the seventh day.” So the people rested on the seventh day. The house of Israel named it manna and it was like coriander seed, white, and its taste was like wafers with honey.
Then Moses said, “This is what Yahweh has commanded: Let an omer full of it be kept throughout your generations that they may see the bread that I fed you in the wilderness when I brought you out of the land of Egypt.
Moses said to Aaron, “Take a jar and put an omer full of manna in it and place it before Yahweh to be kept throughout your generations.” As Yahweh commanded Moses, so Aaron placed it before the testimony to be kept. The sons of Israel ate the manna 40 years until they came to an inhabited land. They ate the manna until they came to the border of the land of Canaan. Now, an omer is a tenth of an ephah.
Okay, lots of fun things are happening in this passage. Let’s make some observations.
Notice verse 1 says that the people came to the wilderness of Sin. Now we know what the word sin means, but this is a location. This is not actually talking about sin, rebellion against God, that kind of sin. This is just a place name. Though it is interesting that sin is what takes place in this wilderness.
This is probably connected to Sinai. It’s got the same root.
In verse 2, we find out that the people are grumbling again. This time against Moses and Aaron. What are they grumbling about this time? Nothing to eat. Lack of food.
Now, what’s strange about Israel’s memory of Egypt in verse 3? Yeah, they said they ate to the full in Egypt. Yeah, that doesn’t seem right. They describe Egypt like it was some kind of food paradise. They’re like, “Oh man, do you remember what we had?” That doesn’t seem a very accurate memory.
They remember it as a paradise rather than a place of oppressive bondage. And according to verse 1, this is only how long after they left Egypt? Yeah, this is the second month. It’s only been a month away and they already have rose-colored glasses looking back at Egypt.
Now, what fact is emphasized about the people’s grumbling against Moses and Aaron in verses 7, 8, 9, and 11? Moses and Aaron say, “You’re not grumbling against us. You’re grumbling against God.” Again and again, they make this point to the people of Israel.
“Again and again they make this point: you’re not grumbling against us—you’re grumbling against God.”
Notice in verse 4, God tells Moses that he will provide food for the people from heaven. And this will be the occasion for another test. God commands the people through Moses that they should gather a certain amount of food per person each day and twice the amount on the sixth day of the week because there will be none on the Sabbath.
Now, it also commands via Moses, verse 19, that the people should leave none of the food over until the following morning. That’s for days 1 to 5.
Now, considering that the people are only to gather enough to fill themselves for one day, why might people be tempted to leave some over until the next morning? Okay. Disobedience, lack of faith. What was someone saying over here? Okay. Well, explain that a little bit more. What does lack of faith have to do with keeping some for the next day?
Yeah. Yeah. Maybe God won’t provide it the next day, so let’s just hedge our bets. Don’t eat the whole thing. Leave a little bit over because we don’t want to be hungry tomorrow or have nothing to eat. They’re trying to ration it.
Manna from Heaven: What Is It?
But it’s ultimately lack of faith. Now, what kind of food does God provide for his people?
God provides bread from heaven, which they call manna, and quail—these big birds.
Now you have to love the name manna.
Verse 15 says they saw the stuff and they said, “What is it?” And that’s what they called it. Mahoo in Hebrew means “what is it?”
The people call it man, which is basically the Hebrew word for “what.” Our term manna comes from an alternate spelling of the word that’s used in Nehemiah 9:20. So we’re eating what? Because we don’t know what it is.
Now, notice where this manna appears.
According to verses 13 to 14, it was a layer on the ground of the wilderness around the camp in the morning like frost, a fine flake-like substance.
Verse 31 tells us that it was like coriander seed, white, and tasted like wafers with honey.
I don’t know about you, but that sounds pretty good. Wafers with honey. Sign me up. Imagine breads and cakes made with manna as flour.
“Manna tasted like wafers with honey—imagine breads and cakes made with manna as flour.”
Notice also in verse 21 that it says manna would melt in the sun. That’s intriguing.
Yet how do the people fail to do what God commands them? It’s multiple ways.
What’s one? That’s right. They didn’t gather the assigned amount. Some took more. Some took less. What else did they fail to do?
Don’t leave any over for days one to five of the week. They did, and it bred worms and became foul. What else did they fail to do?
Some went to gather on the Sabbath, even though God told them ahead of time you’re not going to find any.
Notice, however, the leftovers for the Sabbath did not become foul, even though all the other times it did.
After seeing this last disobedience over the Sabbath, God complains himself in verse 28: “How long do you refuse to keep my commandments and my instructions?”
Israel’s Disobedience and God’s Continued Mercy
Despite the disobedience though, the people are well provided for by God with food. Even for those who didn’t gather the right amount, God made sure everybody had just the right amount that they needed.
And notice the kind of chastening that God brings to people for their complaints and for their disobedience. There’s no punishment, no discipline. Rather, God commands that a portion of manna be put in a jar to serve as a perpetual memorial. That’s in verses 32-34.
Now notice verse 35. Israel, it says, would eat manna for the next 40 years until they finally enter Canaan to inherit the promised land.
Now, Israel goes through a lot during those 40 years and they would be tested many times and many times prove disobedient. Yet manna would fall every night for Israel to gather in the morning and have food even in the barren wilderness.
“Manna would fall every night for Israel to gather in the morning—food for two million people in a barren wilderness.”
And remember for how many people this is. 600,000 men left Egypt. We’re probably talking about close to two million people. All of them have enough food for 40 years.
Let’s turn to interpretation again. How does Israel fail or fare in their second test? Multiple failures.
Now, to be fair, not every single person disobeyed multiple times. It says some did, but the people as a whole, they complained. And then different people within the group, they disobeyed every one of the commands that God gave them.
Here’s a question. How were the people’s grumblings against Moses and Aaron really against God? They say that to them multiple times. How is that true?
Exactly. Glenna says it well. He was the one who was directing Moses and Aaron how to lead the people. So if they complain against these leaders, they’re really complaining against God. And more than that, God gave them these leaders specifically. And he directed them to honor their leaders.
So any complaint against the leaders for multiple reasons was really against God. I told you to honor them. I gave them to you and I myself am directing them. You’re not complaining against them. You’re complaining against me.
More generally, God is sovereign over everything, including these difficult circumstances in which Israel finds itself. Therefore, any sinful complaint about circumstances, even the people who are leading you, is ultimately a sinful complaint about how God runs his world.
And do you realize that this is true for our complaints as well? You may think when you complain, you’re only complaining about a person or about an animal or about an object. But all of these are under God’s sovereign direction.
So when you complain, whom are you really complaining against? God, the king of all.
Now Dwayne, I saw your hand. Was there something you want to add?
Yeah. Dwayne brings up an interesting observation. They complain against Moses and Aaron as if Moses and Aaron had the power to change things and do something about it. But these were beyond their purview.
This is going to have to be God. I think there’s another instance, maybe it already happened in Exodus where God tells Moses to do a certain thing and he’s like, “Should all our flocks be slaughtered so that we can feed all these people?” And God says, “No, I’m going to do it.
Just trust me.” So yeah, this is definitely beyond their ability. So why are the people even complaining to Moses and Aaron? They should be complaining to the one who actually can do something about it, complaining in faith.
Why God Provides Through Means
Here’s another question.
Why does God make the people gather their own food? Because did you notice this? God could have caused a fully cooked meal to appear on the dinner plates of the Israelites all throughout Israel every night. But he doesn’t do this.
Instead, each person has to go out, bend down, gather this flake-like substance to bake into daily bread.
Why did God do it this way?
Say that again, Glenda.
Okay. He apparently wanted them to do some work. Any other answer?
Right. That’s a good observation. It is a tangible way to see faith. It’s putting faith in action. If you just wait there for the dinner plate, it doesn’t really matter whether you believe or not. But if you actually have to go out and do something, now you’re putting your faith into action. That’s a good point.
Ultimately, only God knows in his perfect wisdom why he had to do it this way.
Though it is interesting to note, as both Glenda and Pastor Mark were saying, God reveals himself to be a God who likes to work through means. He often ordains that our work is part of how he provides for us. You ever noticed this?
God says, “Don’t worry, I’m going to provide for you. Oh, by the way, you better go work.” This is how God provides usually.
But God doesn’t always do this. There are times where he says, “I’m going to show you that I don’t need your work. I don’t need your contribution.” For example, in a parallel case, sometimes Israel is called to go out and fight battles that God has already guaranteed will be victorious. Go fight those enemies. I’ll give you the victory. But other times, God says, “You just stand by and watch. I will fight the battle and I will obtain the victory. You won’t lift a finger.”
Why one way, not the other? Well, I think both of those concepts we just talked about are there. God shows I’m a God who uses means. I want you to put your faith into action, but also I want to show you I’m the one with the real power. Don’t trust in your work. Don’t trust in your own skill and ability and wisdom. Trust in me.
And again, that’s a good thing for us to remember for our lives today. We are called to faithful obedience and wise stewardship. But we must remember that provision and power comes entirely from God, not ourselves.
“We are called to faithful obedience and wise stewardship, but provision and power comes entirely from God.”
Next question.
What exactly is mana?
The Hebrews asked a good question. What is it?
And the answer is no one knows. No one knows beyond that it was a special miraculous provision of food from heaven.
Some have sought to identify mana with something called honeydew. And no, I’m not talking about the fruit.
In various parts of the world, there exists a phenomenon called honeydew where insects will bite certain trees and immediately excrete a sweet honeylike substance obtained from the tree.
This substance, which interestingly is called mana today, can be gathered and eaten by animals or by man.
But this modern mana is not the mana of the passage. And how can we know that for sure?
There are no trees. He says you’re going to find it on the ground all around the camp. This is not near trees. This cannot be the excretion of insects.
And by the way, it’s supposed to provide for two million people. I don’t think there are enough trees or enough insects for that.
There is always an effort to explain away the miracles of the Bible as natural phenomena. It’s true, even as we were just saying that God does use means. He sometimes does providently use natural phenomena in the scriptures. But when the details of the passage plainly indicate a supernatural work, we should uphold the work as supernatural.
Now the question: why doesn’t God chasten Israel? They failed again multiple ways. They directly disobeyed him. Why doesn’t he punish them for it?
He is allowed to show mercy whenever he wants to show mercy. And he is fundamentally in his heart gracious.
As we were just saying before, long of nose, he is gracious, loving, and patient. And he decides, I’m going to show that again. I’m going to show that again to my people. He knows that what they’re doing is wrong and an extreme offense to him. Don’t be like, “Well, that was kind of wrong.” No. Any kind of disobedience to God’s law, to God’s direction, is an infinite offense. He’s God. He’s holy. He’s perfectly right. He’s good. And they are sinning against him. Yet, God shows them mercy.
Now, God isn’t always so merciful with Israel. There will be other times, even as we continue on in the Torah, when Israel complains and then God sends a plague.
But poignantly, this only happens after the nation receives God’s law from Mount Sinai and they formally enter into covenant with God with all the terms spelled out.
Additionally, when God does start to chasten them, that will only be after God has shown them and their forefathers grace and patience again and again and again and again. So it’s not like, oh, they just don’t know what kind of God I am yet. No, no, they will know plainly.
But at this beginning stage, God treats Israel the way he treated the patriarchs. He shows grace. Even though there’s lack of faith and even outright contradiction of God’s commands, God shows grace so that the people will learn how good and great God is. They will repent of their sins and they will walk by faith in him.
I compare it to the patriarchs. You remember how Abraham lies about his wife being his sister? I think he does it twice. And he also marries Hagar and has that whole fiasco. God doesn’t punish him for either of those things.
Actually, he makes it work out really well for Abraham. Why? Well, I think we see God’s merciful character, but also this is the beginning stages of God’s revealing himself to his covenant people. He says, “I want to show you. I want to show you in the beginning you can trust me. I will take care of you. I want to be extra patient when you don’t have a big track record to look at.”
Once Israel enters into formal covenant, once the track record is established, he says, “You really ought to know better by now. You now will see that I am holy as well as merciful.”
Okay. Israel’s first two tests are both filled with failure, but God still graciously provides.
Now, what about a test that is a repeat of the first with only slightly different circumstances?
The Third Test: No Water at Rephidim (Exodus 17:1–7)
Let’s look at Exodus 17 for the third test. Exodus 17:1-7.
Because time is beginning to grow short, I’m just going to read this and comment briefly on it. Exodus 17:1-7.
Then all the congregation of the sons of Israel journeyed by stages from the wilderness of Sin according to the command of Yahweh and camped at Rephidim.
And there was no water for the people to drink.
Therefore the people quarreled with Moses and said, “Give us water that we may drink.” And Moses said to them, “Why do you quarrel with me? Why do you test Yahweh?” But the people thirsted there for water.
And they grumbled against Moses and said, “Why now have you brought us up from Egypt to kill us and our children and our livestock with thirst?” So Moses cried out to Yahweh, saying, “What shall I do to this people a little more, and they will stone me?” Then Yahweh said to Moses, “Pass before the people, and take with you some of the elders of Israel, take in your hand your staff with which you struck the Nile, and go.
Behold, I will stand before you there on the rock at Horeb, and you shall strike the rock, and water will come out of it that the people may drink.
And Moses did so in the sight of the elders of Israel. He named the place Massa and Meribah because of the quarrel of the sons of Israel, and because they tested Yahweh, saying, “Is Yahweh among us or not?”
Does Israel pass their third test? No. In fact, their behavior is worse than the previous two times. Moses even fears for his life.
But what does God do again? God does not send any judgment. Again, he graciously provides this time by having Moses strike a certain rock on an outcrop of the Mount Sinai mountain range and he has water come out of the rock.
Moses though knows that what the people have done is wrong. Therefore, Moses names the place Massa and Meribah. Massa means test or testing, and Meribah means quarreling or contention.
“God wanted Israel to remember their own sinfulness as well as his gracious patience and provision.”
God wanted Israel to remember their own sinfulness and lack of faith as well as his gracious patience and provision.
So then, bringing it all together, what is the main message of these three passages today? What did God want the people of Israel to know when Moses originally wrote these things?
Surely, two of the main messages are the sinfulness of complaining and God’s fundamental grace and patience and provision.
Remember this Torah, this book, it was written primarily for the second generation of Israel that’s about to go into the promised land. And God speaks to them through Moses so that this new generation will not do as their forefathers did—complaining, doubting, disobeying—but instead listen to God, trust him, and obey.
Yet, as we observed earlier, what Israel experienced was also partly for our instruction to transform us in the way that we live today. So we too should look at this and learn, trust God and obey him.
Application: The Sin of Complaining
This brings us to step three of our whole inductive Bible study method where we talk about application. Let’s do that by drilling down a bit more on complaining. I’ve got three questions to help us explore this sin and how to deal with it.
What types of things do people tend to complain about in an unrighteous way? Brainstorm with me.
Complain about food. Complain about being uncomfortable.
Somebody have a hand. Go ahead, Glenda.
The economy. Yes. What else?
Yes, JMA.
Complain about other people. Complain about the weather. Complain about our own comforts and convenience generally speaking. What are some other specific things though?
Politics. Maybe even people talking about politics.
Complain about sleep or the lack of it.
Complain about money or the lack of it.
Complain about machines that don’t work. How many of you ever been frustrated by your printer or your laptop or your network?
Bad service when you go to a certain place. I don’t mean like bad service, but you can complain about that too. But I mean how other people are treating you? Poor health, your looks or your body image, your work, your church, your ministry, your boss, your leadership, other people. I mean, yeah, when we get to the end of this list, it probably will sound like everything.
We complain about people we know. We complain about people we don’t know. We complain about children. We complain about our children and other people’s children.
We complain about difficult circumstances. We complain about people’s sin against us. We complain about animals and pets. We complain about sports performances. And we complain about other people who complain.
“We complain about people we know, people we don’t know, children, animals, sports—pretty much everything.”
What Drives Our Complaining? The Idols of the Heart
But as I think Pastor Mark was getting us to our second question, what’s at the core of this? What thoughts and beliefs in the heart motivate and lead to our sinful complaining?
Okay, Danny says, “Pride.” Other thoughts.
What’s at the root of complaining? Yes, Jose.
I deserve something and I’m not getting it. That aligns very closely with pride. I think I heard somebody talking over here, Pastor Mark.
Yeah, it’s very self-focused, self-centered. It’s not concerned with God’s agenda. Judy, did I see your hand?
No. Okay.
Yeah. Fundamentally, there’s a lack of contentment because you say, “There’s something I need that I’m not getting.” You may notice already there’s a lot of parallels with complaining and anger.
Even when we were talking about conflicts last week in church, what is the source of your quarreling and conflicts? He says it is the desires, or rather it’s the pleasures that you desire. The things that you think are going to make you happy and make you feel content. It’s the same thing with our complaining.
What do you complain about? The things that you think will make you happy. Something’s getting in the way and so you complain about it.
It’s just another manifestation of the wrong worship of the heart. You’re not satisfied in God. You’re looking for satisfaction in something else. You’re not getting it. So you complain. You’re manifesting heart worship of an idol.
So complaining is fundamentally a lack of trust in God’s provision, a lack of reliance on God’s wisdom, a lack of belief in God’s goodness and his doing good to us in every circumstance, a lack of love for God, a lack of satisfaction in God, and it is a belief that there is some particular thing that you need at a particular time to be happy, which is idolatry.
“Complaining is fundamentally a lack of trust in God’s provision and a belief that something other than God will make you happy.”
So complaining is a symptom sin. It’s a symptom of a greater sin of the heart. And that’s why Israel keeps turning to it.
And that’s why God will say to Israel later, “You are not circumcised in heart. That’s why you won’t trust me. That’s why you don’t love me. That’s why you keep turning back to the things of this world to make you happy.”
How Serious Is God About Complaining?
Okay. Now, how serious is God about complaining? I remember a preacher pointing out something profound in 1 Corinthians 10:1-13. We have some famous verses from that section. It’s a warning against idolatry, but based on Israel’s experience.
The interesting thing that the preacher pointed out is that the last verse of the previous chapter—or close to the last verse—Paul talked about, “I discipline my body and make it my slave so that I will not be disqualified after I’ve preached.” What did he mean by disqualified?
Well, if you just go on into 1 Corinthians 10, you learn all about Israel being disqualified from entering the promised land.
What kind of things does Paul point out as disqualifying them? Idolatry, immorality, testing God, and complaining.
Look at 1 Corinthians 10:10. He says, “Nor grumble as some of them did and were destroyed by the destroyer.” What’s the implication?
1 Corinthians 10:10: “Nor grumble as some of them did and were destroyed by the destroyer.”
If you do not repent of your complaining and of the heart idols that motivate it, you will be destroyed. You will be disqualified. You will never enter God’s promised land.
Does that shock you?
God is a holy God. Complaining is a manifestation of idolatry. God says, “I will not give my glory to another. You are to be holy as I am holy.” Now, God is gracious and patient, even as we saw in our passage. Yet, we must not use that as an excuse for sin.
Putting On Contentment and Trust in Christ
If you are in Christ, you must set aside the idolatry of heart that leads to complaining.
You must instead put on the simple satisfaction of knowing God and resting in his perfect provision for you in your life at the right time, in the right way. He will give you exactly what you need.
Ultimately, if you believe in the Lord, your heart needs to be able to say, “All I need, all I truly need is God, and whatever he chooses is right for me.” God is a good father. He’s not going to be miserly with you. He’s not like, “Well, you’ll just have to get by with that.” He says, “This is the perfect provision for you. I’m giving this to you in love. You might not understand it, but this is exactly right. Trust me.”
If we will humble ourselves and do that, we’ll be blessed. We will be happy. And we will worship God as we ought.
But if we do not, we should beware God’s chastening and even God’s eternal judgment.
Let us not complain in an unrighteous way. Let us complain in a righteous way.
Go to God with your needs. Go to him based on his promises. Go in faith.
But do not go in unbelief. Wait for God’s perfect provision. At the right time, he will bring it. When it arrives, you will stand out from this world. The scriptures say by not grumbling or disputing, we stand out as bright stars in the middle of a world of darkness.
“By not grumbling or disputing, we stand out as bright stars in the middle of a world of darkness.”
That’s Philippians again. God, by his spirit and by his word, enables us to do this. We absolutely need his help and we must confess and repent of where we have failed. But he is gracious. He is forgiving and he is transforming.
Let us fundamentally, based on this lesson, put aside complaining. Put aside idolatry and put on thankfulness and contentment in Christ.
All right, that’s it for our time today. Next time we’re back in Sunday school, we are looking at a very profound moment in history. Israel reaches Sinai. God appears to them, speaks to them, and gives them his law.
We’ll talk about that next time. Let’s close in prayer.
Heavenly Father, we confess that we are guilty of complaining. We complain in our hearts, but frequently, God, we complain out loud. We complain about people that are made in your image. We complain about the things of your world that you are perfectly arranging in your wise sovereignty.
God, we confess, even as Moses and Aaron say, “We complain against you. We complain against you, the good God, the holy God, the perfect king. We complain against you.”
Forgive us, God. Forgive us for this great sin and for the idols that are motivating it, where we think there’s something else that I need that’s not God and God hasn’t given it to me, so I can’t be happy.
Oh Lord, as David says, create in us, continue that work of creating in us a clean heart. Purge out our iniquity. Help us to cast aside the idols and instead, God, give us that clear view of the beauty and goodness of Christ.
Help us to see, God, that you are everything that we need and that your provision for our lives, however you determine it, is right and good.
Oh God, help us to be patient when other people complain and direct them back to you and to contentment in Christ.
Help us not to complain but help us, God, to just enjoy the eternal life we have knowing you. In Jesus’ name, amen.
All right. Thank you everyone.
